DOE Home Page

 

Peer Review Subgroup

Charter

Rev.0

Effective Date:   October 2007

(PDF Copy)

Purpose

The SSR Peer Review Working Subgroup is an Energy Facility Contractors Group (EFCOG) Working Subgroup that focuses on peer review of EFCOG contractors and subcontractors noncompliance determination and reporting programs.   Peer review is a mechanism that promotes enhanced communication, lessons learned, and process improvement across the Department of Energy (DOE) complex in the area of noncompliance determination and reporting within the Price-Anderson Amendments Act (PAAA), Worker Safety and Health (WSH), and Security programs.

Objectives

The objectives of SSR Peer Review Working Subgroup are to:

  • Provide assessments of PAAA, WSH, and Security noncompliance determination and reporting programs based on Department of Energy published assessment criteria.  These assessments are conducted on behalf of the assessed organizations and the reports are the property of the assessed organization.   If the assessed organization agrees, the reports may be published on the DOE EFCOG website.

  • Use the information gained from conducting the peer reviews to promote on-going improvements and lessons learned across the DOE complex in the areas of interest to the DOE Office of Enforcement.

  • Provide additional complex-wide enforcement program implementation information to the Office of Enforcement (OE).

Scope

The SSR Peer Review Subgroup will operate within the scope of EFCOG and the SSR Working Group.   The subgroup will serve as a facilitator for coordination of peer review efforts for contractor/subcontractors who are members of EFCOG by implementing the OE guidance for the determination and reporting of noncompliances for the nuclear safety, worker safety and health, and security rules. 

Organization

Members of the Peer Review Subgroup are volunteers from the members of the EFCOG SSR Working Group.

The Point of Contact (POC) of the Peer Review Subgroup will be selected by the Strategic Planning Committee (SPC) of the SSR Working Group and will serve for a maximum of two years, unless extended by the SPC.  The POC will coordinate the activities of the Subgroup.

This charter and any revisions will be approved by the Chair of the SSR Working Group.

Process

The peer reviews will be conducted per an established schedule using a subgroup approved procedure and checklist.  The checklist will be based on DOE-OE guidelines for assessing PAAA, WSH, and Security programs contained in the OE Enforcement Overview Process.

Information from the peer reviews, if the assessed organization concurs, will be posted on an EFCOG website for facilitation of complex-wide lessons learned.

Duties of the Peer Review Subgroup will include:

  • Coordinate the schedule of peer reviews for requesting contractors/subcontractors

  • Develop and maintain the Peer Review procedure and checklist(s).

  • Work with the EFCOG web-master to post applicable procedures and peer review results.

  • Report at least annually to the SSR Working Group the results and lessons learned in conducting peer reviews.

  • Maintain qualification requirements of assessors and a roster of qualified peer reviewers.

Deliverables

The Peer Review Reports will be posted on the EFCOG website as requested by OE and agreed to by each site, to continue the lessons learned benefit previously provided by past OE Program Reviews.

An annual summary of the activities of the subgroup will be presented to the SSR Working Group by the POC of the Peer Review Subgroup.